1. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2001
Posts
131
Post Likes
You have two glasses in front of you. One is full of orange juice and the other is equally full of lemonaide. You remove one spoonfull of lemonaide and put it into the orange juice, then one spoonfull of this mixture and put it back into the lemonaide.Is there more orange juice in the lemonaide or lemonaide in the orange juice?.

2. Guy
Regular Member
Join Date
Jan 2001
Posts
1,373
Post Likes
Let's see...suppose that one spoonfull equals 1% of the total contents of a given glass.

1: When you put the spoonfull of lemonaide(L) in the orange(O) juice, you now have 100 parts O and 1 part L, so the orange juice is now 99.001% pure (100/101).

2: Assuming that the two are first mixed thoroughly before one spoonful of that is taken out, you are now adding a mixture of 99.001% O and 0.999 % L to the lemonade glass. This means that you now have 99 parts L (remember, you took one part out) plus 0.999% of 1 part newly added that is also lemonade. So the lemonade glass now has 99.00999 parts L and .99001 part O. This means that the purity of the lemonade is: 99.00999/100 = 99.00999%

So the lemonade glass is purer, and thus there is more lemonade in the glass of orange juice.

If the percentage of a spoonful in relation to a glassfull is other than 1%, then the difference in purity varies proportionally.

3. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2001
Posts
131
Post Likes

## Incorrect

Nice try though Guy.

4. Regular Guest
Join Date
Aug 2001
Location
Upper Great Lakes
Posts
94
Post Likes

## <voiceover by Columbo>

Y’ know, Guy’s explanation seems well-thought-out and everything, but there’s just one thing about it that bothers me. There is one thing that just doesn't add up. If the glasses end up equally full at the end of the exchange, then whatever amount of lemonade moved from one glass to the other must equal the amount of orange juice that moved in the opposite direction. That would mean they are of equal purity in the end – neither is purer!

This one is easier to solve without a calculator. All those nines and zeros get jumbled up!

5. Regular Guest
Join Date
Apr 2001
Posts
841
Post Likes

## Good Grief

Marilyn Savant and Columbo just showed up. Actually I like both.

6. Guy
Regular Member
Join Date
Jan 2001
Posts
1,373
Post Likes
Carl sure has that simple but good point, the fact that both glasses are brought to the same volume means that their concentrations will be opposite but equal. So I must have muffed up somewhere!

Join Date
Sep 2000
Location
Pekin, IL USA
Posts
700
Post Likes

## There is more lemonaide in the orange juice.

The reason being is that you are adding one spoonfull of 100% pure lemonaide to the orange juice. A spoonfull of this mixture is less than 100% orange juice because of the percentage of lemonaide mixed with it.

8. Professional Member
Join Date
Oct 2001
Posts
6,071
Post Likes

## Insufficient information

After the lemonade is added to the orange juice, is it stirred throughly? If so, you would then have one glass with X amount minus 1 teaspoon, then another glass with X amount plus one teaspoon. The glass with +1 contains a diluted mixture, and when a teaspoon is removed, the diluted misture contains both lemonade and orange juice. Added back to the lemonade, you have brought the two glasses back to X amount each. But, you just added lemonade and orange juice back to the lemonade, so the orange juice is more contaminated than the lemonade.

But, if you just added the teaspoon of lemonade to the orange juice and did not stir vigorously, you then scooped mostly lemonade from the orange juice, leavely each glass about equally contaminated.

This is the intuitive, serious answer, but I still suspect some joke is forthcoming. Something along the lines of, "The glass was COMPLETELY full, so the lemonade just ran over the side of the orange juice glass."

9. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2001
Posts
131
Post Likes

## Bama, Information is sufficient

Doesnt matter if stirred skimmed or whatever.Here is another way to view this. There is an absence of one substance,dont know axactly how much but we do know that another substance made up for the void. So the exact amount that is missing has to be the exact amount that was made up for or one glass would contain more liquid. Therefore each glass is equally contaminated.

10. Professional Member
Join Date
Jul 2000
Location
Dallas,Texas
Posts
5,138
Post Likes
I have to agree with Guy and Bama. The percentages in each spoonful were not equal as your last statement (Nate) would imply. Volume may be equal but concentration can not be in this scenario.

11. Professional Member
Join Date
Oct 2001
Posts
6,071
Post Likes
I'm thinking how to explain this to you, but, if there is even one molecule of lemonade in the mixture you put back in the lemonade glass, then you have more lemonade in the orange juice. Volume here is not the significant variable.

12. Professional Member
Join Date
Oct 2001
Posts
6,071
Post Likes

## Darn! I was wrong!

While thinking of the solution, I realized I was wrong. Here is the way I thought of explaining it, and it comes out the same every time.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~

OK, let’s look at it this way:

13. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2001
Posts
131
Post Likes

## Bama

Excellent explanation. No matter what the combination of beads, as long as there is the same amount of beads in each container the colors are equal but opposite

Page 1 of 2 12 Last

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•

## Related Forums

The place where Electrical professionals meet.