1. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2010
Posts
8
Post Likes

## TXV flow rate

Hello all, I am new to this site and was wondering if anyone could help me with a problem I am trying to answer. I am currently attending a technical school for HVACR and am filling out a academic excellence test. The question I cannot solve nor find in my text book is, as follows: "What is the flow rate of a TXV in a r410a system as compared to the flow rate of a TXV in a r22 system". The answer choices are: A-equal, B-40 to 70% higher, C-15% greater, D-15% less.
Has anyone here perchance, ever came across this info? If so could you let me in on the solution. Thanks for your time everyone.

Maximo

2. Professional Member
Join Date
Oct 2010
Location
Syracuse, NY
Posts
17
Post Likes
I would think equal. 410 is higher pressure. Both work on the same principle, superheat since they use a TXV. I also am in school so i may be wrong.
Last edited by oldplanemech; 11-16-2010 at 11:09 PM. Reason: addition

3. Professional Member
Join Date
Sep 2008
Location
Western PA
Posts
26,671
Post Likes
Think about how much refrigerant would be required to absorb equal amounts of heat.

4. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2010
Posts
8
Post Likes
Thanks for your replies. I am leaning towards the answer of "equal" also since I don't remember being told that r410 absorbs heat more efficiently than 22, only that it is more "environmentally friendly". It does operate at higher pressure but the TXV and all other system components are designed for that. If the heat absorption capabilities are equal and the two systems are equal in tonnage then the flow rate should regulate superheat identically. My only question now is if I am correct in assuming the heat absorption characteristics to be the same between the two. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.

5. Professional Member
Join Date
Sep 2008
Location
Western PA
Posts
26,671
Post Likes
Originally Posted by Maximo3
Thanks for your replies. I am leaning towards the answer of "equal" also since I don't remember being told that r410 absorbs heat more efficiently than 22, only that it is more "environmentally friendly". It does operate at higher pressure but the TXV and all other system components are designed for that. If the heat absorption capabilities are equal and the two systems are equal in tonnage then the flow rate should regulate superheat identically. My only question now is if I am correct in assuming the heat absorption characteristics to be the same between the two. Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
Maybe a bit of research on your part would benefit you.

I'm sure the answer is close at hand, you just have to find it.

6. Professional Member
Join Date
Oct 2010
Location
SW Michigan, near Battle Creek
Posts
921
Post Likes
410a is supposed to have higher volumetric heat. so it should take less of it to do the same job. so flow should be less. I think.

7. Professional Member
Join Date
Aug 2010
Location
Wichita Fall, Tx
Posts
77
Post Likes
Don't you hate it when you ask a question, then get a question not a answer?
I've also heard that no question is a dumb question, but thats not the case for some of the answers.

8. Professional Member
Join Date
Sep 2008
Location
Western PA
Posts
26,671
Post Likes
Originally Posted by WFL-TX
Don't you hate it when you ask a question, then get a question not a answer?
I've also heard that no question is a dumb question, but thats not the case for some of the answers.
In my experience, simply giving a student or an apprentice the answers turns them into idiots that can't think for themselves.

I very often answer questions like this with directed questions to help them think in the right direction.

Nothing personal.

9. Originally Posted by fearlessfurnace
410a is supposed to have higher volumetric heat. so it should take less of it to do the same job. so flow should be less. I think.
Yep. Lower volumetric flow.

10. Max.

The answer IS in your text books. You have to read them more then once. I know. They can be a bit boring sometimes(I'm still trying to finish my first one ).

Often. It can help to write down in your own words what you read.

11. Max,

as you know? there are 12,000 btu's per hour or 288,000 btu's in 24 hours

if you need 12k btu's? in your evaporator?

you need to find how many btus per pound in r-22 and

how many btu's per pound in r-410a

this can be found on an enthalpy chart

if you know the enthalpy and density of the refrigerant?

you will then know which one needs more FLOW!

the refrigerant with the MOST btu's per pound would require LESS refrigerant .

by the way, here is a nice refrigerant piping web site.
http://www.mcquayservice.com/mcquayb...011_120407.pdf

you might like it?

12. Regular Guest
Join Date
Nov 2010
Posts
8
Post Likes

## Thanks again all

You guys were very helpful. I went ahead and asked my instructor about this question, and he also directed my attention to the enthalpy characteristics of the two refrigerants. Turns out the flow rate for r410a is less since it does absorb quite a bit more btu per volume. I realized it takes less of the r410 to absorb as much heat as the r22. I have to admit, i wouldn't have gone to the enthalpy chart so soon had I not asked for help, but hey , Im here to learn. You have all been quite helpful, thanks again.

13. good job Max!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 1 of 2 12 Last

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•

## Related Forums

The place where Electrical professionals meet.