In my opinion, with the way the economy is, go with the company that's going to be around longer. Shops go under all the time so choose wisely. Another factor to consider is which company is more likely to support you when times are tough? I worked for a shop once that didn't have hours due to a new construction flop, but they paid us for 32 every week regardless. If you find a company like that, youre blessed. Above everything else, you've gotta do what's right for you, but make sure youre not just thinking about the short term.