Just goes to show, NATE does not a good technician make. Takes lots of other stuff. Ask friends or relatives in your area for their suggestions on a good company.
A good HVAC tech knows how, an educated HVAC tech knows why!
An independent survey,showed NATE techs had 20% less recalls.
I think this was done by Service Round Table.
No ,it's not the end all,but it's a good measure,IMHO.
Would you know if that is a recent survey.
Or was it done early on?
I think it was two to three years ago.
But NATE nor 35 years doesn't mean that you aren't a hack.
I've seen techs with 35 years don't want to learn and are sloppy and lazy in their work.
The hope of NATE is encouraging one to keep learning IMO.
NATE nor 35 years can't stop a bad day nor Assure skills and work ethic.
If you help others then you are a Success
Holy crap I think this thread started out as a vibration problem and it turned into a NATE bashing party!
It would be nice to have some sort of certification like auto mechanics have ASE and such but it will only work if everyone makes it work.
About this vibration problem...
How about some more variables to consider. How about taking a picture of the outdoor unit so we can have a look-see at the install.
I was called out once for a vibration from an outdoor unit and it was because the new construction builder mounted the outdoor unit on a platform that mounted to the foundation of the house 2 feet above the pitched yard.
It was just vibration transfer through the metal through the concrete and into her floor joists.
Some common sense can go a long way.
back on topic.
"That motor's done, he let the factory smoke charge out!"
They have it already, Its called NATE!
Originally Posted by smoke
Why would we want to MAKE it work. All you're doing is letting some third party come in, take your money to give you tests, and convince the whole public that if you're not certified through them, you shouldn't be allowed to touch their equipment! All so some big fat man can live in his mansion and you pay his bills. Count me out! I don't need an outsider to tell me what I know!
Originally Posted by smoke
No Heat No Cool You need Action Fast
Experience is a hard teacher because she gives the test first, the lesson afterwards". -Vernon Law-
"Never let success go to your head, and never let failure go to your heart". - Unknown
"To face tragedy is the greatest challenge; to overcome tragedy is the greatest success" -Ranal Currie-
I might as well add my 2 cents on NATE and training.
I have done training the last 7 years. I have found there are good young and older techs. There are some not too good young and older techs. There are people who can learn in seminars and some that use field experience as their seminar. The only down side to learning in the field is when being taught by others in the field and you also learn their old bad habits. The classroom will teach the proper way it should be done. That does not mean it is the only way to do something. An instructor should teach the whys of why something is done not just how. Take a look at the idea of pumping away from the expansion tank. This came about almost 50 years ago. There are many who do not do it today. Return side circulators may have been the way they were taught or the way they always have done it. An instructors job is to teach why it must be moved. The circulators have changed, so old 3 piece circulators removed air with water volume and the wet rotor pumps must do it by adding pressure to the system. If the instructor just says it must be moved the why was not answered.
The industry is changing so rapidly today we need schools to keep up with the changes. I see in my classes some people do not apply what they learn when I need to visit the problem job site after the class. The class gives you the basics and a better understanding of how it is supposed to work but no school will take the place of, after learning the basis building you own troubleshooting skills and fact finding missions.