Quote Originally Posted by royc View Post
Didnt say illegal, said "back door style". Of course that depends on what "IS" is in illegal..<grin>

http://www.givemeliberty.org/feature...otratified.htm

Roy
Read your link Roy, your too kind. It sure sounded illegal to me. Several states did not ratify the amendment as a income tax and it had nothing to do with the amendment but were counted anyhow in the approval column. I would have to say that this amendment is illegal and should never have been incorporated into the Constitution. But with a left wing Supreme Court they would never rule against it any more than they would they would against the 14th Amendment.