need help !Carrier vs Lennox
I have quotes to install a new central AC system in a 2,800 sqft house in NewEngland
I norrowed it down to two companies that have been around a while and hopefully will do a good install
1st a Lennox XC13-042-230 3.5 ton (up to 15 seer rating from web page)
Lennox CBX32M-042-230 air handler
2nd quote a Carrier 24ACA3 4 ton 13 seer 10 yr limited warranty on compressor
Carrier FX4CNF048 410a coil blower (a couple grand more for install)
not sure why it's off a 1/2 ton
I have read Rheem/Ruud or Trane makes a better unit should I consider getting a dealer for that instead?
any help would be great thanks
Last edited by kangaroo5; 03-20-2007 at 05:44 PM.
Originally Posted by kangaroo5
Well I am a little bias since I sell RUUD but I would put RUUD up against anything on the market, and you will find it's hard to beat RUUD's Mod. furnace.
Experience is a hard teacher because she gives the test first, the lesson afterwards". -Vernon Law-
"Never let success go to your head, and never let failure go to your heart". - Unknown
"To face tragedy is the greatest challenge; to overcome tragedy is the greatest success" -Ranal Currie-
The equipment is only a component in the HVAC system that the contractor you choose will be building for you.
Regardless of name on the equipment you need to choose the contractor that can build the best system for your needs & then be able to verify it actually is doing what he told you it would.
Keep in mind that those SEER ratings only apply to laboratory conditions, your home isn't a lab.
Have you set up a Google alert for Carbon Monoxide yet?
Click here to find out how.
That model is cooling only on the Lennox-No heatpump?
Since they aren't getting a furnace,guess that leaves Rude out!lol!!
Originally Posted by mrbillpro
Go Carrier,that's what's we sell!
Yes AC only
but I will be looking into a oil fired furnace soon (Buderus)
Spend a few extra $$$ and spring for the XC15. Gets you a much nicer, quieter outdoor unit and the LSOM (Lennox Systems Operation Monitor).
There is nothing more frightful than ignorance in action....Mark Twain
Lennox all the way. Don't waste your time with Carrier.
I like Lennox better than Carrier. I just put a new Lennox XP19 in my house. But I am at least as biased as the RUUD guy.
As to the size difference, Did either contractor do a load calculation, or did they size it based on square feet of floor area. Not doing a full load calculation would be a mistake.
Put a Goodman in and pocket some money. I hate Carrier and Lennox.
Have you hugged the Earth today?
Donny Baker rules
thats brand bashing, but i agree!
Originally Posted by dash
Pick the better contractor see if they did a load calculation
Carrier and Lennox both make comparable equipment. Go with the contractor that makes you more comfortable. Ask to see their load calculations the one that actually ran them is more competent. Maybe the both did a load calc but I doubt it. At 2800 square feet 3.5 tons sounds low especially if you have a number of windows. There is no substitute for a load calculation.
get the lennox and a heat pump model Xp14 or 15 its cheaper heat than oil or LPG should be good to 30 degrees the turn on oil