Recommendations from all of you TRANE centrifugal Guru's
TearDown Recommendation Questions !! CVHF (1200 tonner)
I have seen in some books where it states that you should do a teardown inspection every 30,000 hours
If Im correct with my math then we are looking at exactly 3.43 years assuming that the thing never stops running due to the application of the chiller.
Some state 5-10 years and this needs done. I would assume on a standard HVAC application.
If this is correct. Just how in depth do they recommend going for the teardown. Complete ? Just visual and tolerance checks? Plus new gaskets and seals during reinstallation ?
Im assuming a full removal of components, new oil, ....... the whole 9 yards !!
Would there be any bearings / particular items that you would change reguardless. Any reason to balance the impeller ?
I would obviously do an EDDY at that time.
Just trying to see what everyone out there in TRANEVILLE have to say.
I thought "book says 40k hours"
Me personally would do vibration analysis yearly, by reputable tech.
Eddy Current every 5 yrs
There's NO reason to do an exploratory teardown on one of these chillers based on running hours alone. Do annual oil analysis and vibration analysis. Keep an eye on the purge pumpout minutes. If these things are ok, and there are no vibrations, noises, or motor faults like an open rotor or a bent shaft, then it's probably good! Oil analysis is necessary for the front bearing, impellers, and seals. Vibration analysis (or at the very least, a screwdriver and finely tuned ear) is required to determine the condition of the back bearing. I've got chillers I take care of that have 75k-100k hours on the original bearings, seals, gaskets, and o-rings. They're leak free, and the oil/vibe always comes back good!
The key to happiness is lower expectations.
Don't pick the fly crap out of the pepper.
And thats what I was sure was going to be one answer. I did find some literature that Trane says to do the 30,000/5-10year recommendations.
Customer brought it up. Not sure why. Maybe since they have had issues in the past and are being cautious.
Either way I am curious what everyone who works on these have to say.
As with all equipment the answer is it depends. With proper maintainence and a little tlc I have seen the smaller ones (025,032) go over 80,000 hrs with only a few econo gasket changes. If the chiller runs loaded 24/7 it will run longer. Yearly vibration analysis, oil analysis, and keeping purge minutes low are important. Not many customers want to spend the money on a teardown if there are no problems. After 5- 10 yrs gaskets and O rings tend to dry out and crack with leaks showing up in the jacking bolt holes. Except for oil seals, nose and interstage seals seldom need to be replaced unless there is a lot of surging going on. Outboard bearing issues seem to be more of a problem on the larger compressors. Sometimes teardown inspections at a certain number of hours do get written into contracts but I believe a machine will tell you when it needs service.
as stated before, vibration analysis, oil analysis and watch the purge minutes. if they say good, keep it running. before the previous tests were readily available, 40-50k hours was the number. today, we have better methods.
Someday, I hope to be just as brave as Harry Stamper.
megger readings dropping can lead to one along with the acid tests..and all is shown on the starter contacts over a season ....definitly an oil delivery problem into the bearings
Originally Posted by Hoopstir
If your work speaks for itself, don't interrupt. ~Henry J. Kaiser
Agree with all the posts, Trane used to recommend 10 year overhauls. That's gone by the wayside, but there are customers who will spend the money to overhaul machines (problems or not) because that's what they think is proper. Now do they have to? No. But if it gives them piece of mind. It keeps me working.
Sic Semper Tyrannis.