Reply to Thread

I never said I took a shower...

I will make it a point to take some pics of failed dielectric unions and nipples and right along side of solid brass ones that show no signs of deterioration or galvanic corrosion. There are thousand of these nipples and unions all over the hospital. It very well could (and probably does) have something to do with local water supplies.

Anyway 2sac, I'm glad you got it in and finally took a shower. I'm sure the people around you appreciate it.

I don't know if my shop does business at plumbing supply houses. I called the supply house we buy our commercial water heaters from. It's a 6 year natural draft. Nothing but a tank and a burner. Can't imagine they are all that different.

We can typically buy a heater at a hardware cheaper than supplier. There excuse was big box had a large supply of tanks that weren't up to current code with safety's therefore were cheaper.

thee is no chance a tank from a box store would go in my home.... and also no way they are cheaper at the box store in my area..... probably $200.00 less at supplier..... and there better tanks.....

Originally Posted by 2sac

Fixed that for you. Remember I got a bum arm.

Lol as long as warm water hits the sink its all the same!

Originally Posted by Joehvac25

Are we going to see it on the wall of shame?

Fixed that for you. Remember I got a bum arm.

Originally Posted by 2sac

I put in the 6 year Richmond this morning. Was $100 cheaper at Menards than an AO Smith from the supply house.

Are we going to see it on the wall of fame?

I put in the 6 year Richmond this morning. Was $100 cheaper at Menards than an AO Smith from the supply house.

When we did low income jobs we would add an anode rod in the hot supply for the 12 year warranty

Stay with the 6 year warranty . A friend of mine told me that when he was in the plumbing bussiness they sold a 12year warranty water heater. The difference in the unit was that he would open the box and put a "12 year warranty" sticker on the side of the heater. That was the only difference. You paid more but got the same equipment. Through good engineering the six year unit usually lasts little more than 6 yrs. Just like a 5 year car battery. If you get over 5 years out of it you are LUCKY.

Originally Posted by ammoniadog

I don't think this is true. Brass can successfully be used as a type of dialectic buffer between steel and copper. I don't remember the exact specifics, but it has something to do with the nobility rating of the metals. Steel is on one end of the scale, copper is on the other end of the scale, and brass is about in the middle. Using enough brass in between the steel and copper will prevent electrolysis.

Many plumbers agree with you, but I haven't seen any data or science to support this belief. I did find these nuggets:

If dissimilar metals are used in a piping system, galvanic corrosion can occur even when no electrical devices are attached. The same principle that makes batteries work makes a battery out of a piping system with two different metals. Say you connect copper pipe to galvanized pipe. For battery/electrochemical reasons that it isn't really necessary to understand, electrons will try to flow from the copper pipe to the galvanized pipe. To balance the charges, this will cause some of the copper to dissolve into the water as positively charged ions, migrate through the water, and rejoin the electrons, and copper will deposit on the galvanized pipe. This copper came from the copper pipe, so it's a problem. If you install a dielectric union, it's just like turning off a switch on a battery operated system -- the electrons stop flowing. Dielectric unions are for the purpose of stopping these galvanic currents, and they work.

http://www.finishing.com/268/01.shtml

There is an old plumber''s tale that installing brass nipples in a steel tank is good, while putting copper fittings in steel is bad. If you look at the galvanic scale, you''ll see that copper and brass are side-by-side. Bronze, too. So, they all are going to force steel to rust. We''ve made that test. Galvanized steel screwed into brass will start rusting within days.

http://www.watertechonline.com/artic...ng-rid-of-odor

Originally Posted by Space Racer

Uninsulated brass nipples and unions are not a good idea because you still have metal to metal contact. It doesn't matter which metal you use in between the steel and copper.

What matters is that you connect steel to steel and copper to copper (or brass), and that you have insulators between the steel tank and the copper pipe.

I don't think this is true. Brass can successfully be used as a type of dialectic buffer between steel and copper. I don't remember the exact specifics, but it has something to do with the nobility rating of the metals. Steel is on one end of the scale, copper is on the other end of the scale, and brass is about in the middle. Using enough brass in between the steel and copper will prevent electrolysis.

According to this explanation, dielectric nipples work because they prevent water from coming in contact with the metals at their point of connection. The dielectric effect is enhanced by the water, which acts as an "electrolyte solution."

http://waterheaterreviews.com/what-i...lectric-nipple

Originally Posted by ammoniadog

Why is this a much better idea? Is it because the dielectric unions are more prone to leaking, or is there another reason that I haven't thought of?

How about using brass nipples, and then a brass union that is threaded on one side, and soldered to the copper on the other side, instead of the flex connector? Would that work?

Copper flex connectors and dielectric unions work well because they have plastic inserts in them which serve as insulators. The inserts prevent contact between dissimilar metals. Copper flex connectors are easier to install, but they are thin and corrugated, so may be subject to earlier failure.

Uninsulated brass nipples and unions are not a good idea because you still have metal to metal contact. It doesn't matter which metal you use in between the steel and copper.

What matters is that you connect steel to steel and copper to copper (or brass), and that you have insulators between the steel tank and the copper pipe.

I don't what the feature of dielectric nipples is that makes them insulators.

The dieelectric unions I installed 9 years ago haven't failed. Was busy today and I never checked pricing at the supply house

Originally Posted by ammoniadog

Why is this a much better idea? Is it because the dielectric unions are more prone to leaking, or is there another reason that I haven't thought of?

How about using brass nipples, and then a brass union that is threaded on one side, and soldered to the copper on the other side, instead of the flex connector? Would that work?

Yes, of course it will. I like the flex connectors because they are easy and forgiving. The di-electric unions and nipples work but will eventually fail, you guessed it, to electrolysis. My plumbers replace them all over the hospital nearly everyday. Steel hot water tanks and brass nipples get along very well. Steel and anything else do not.

Originally Posted by Cooked

A much better idea is to use brass nipples and copper flex connectors with brass nuts.

Why is this a much better idea? Is it because the dielectric unions are more prone to leaking, or is there another reason that I haven't thought of?

How about using brass nipples, and then a brass union that is threaded on one side, and soldered to the copper on the other side, instead of the flex connector? Would that work?

Originally Posted by Space Racer

.......To make your heater last, install it with dielectric nipples or unions (if you have copper pipe)........

A much better idea is to use brass nipples and copper flex connectors with brass nuts.

Last 50gal I bought was 275$ from supply house, Bradford white, about a month ago.