yet another noob "which one" question

[richamor]

Goodman GPH 15M or York BHQ.

Both package units, 3 ton, 15Kw strip heat. The Goodman has a higher SEER but the York has a high HSPF.

And both are priced the same.

Your wisdom would be much appreciated.Thanks

:couch:

[beenthere]

Look at the total specs.
Heating BTU output at low outdoor temps.
Cooling BTU capacity at high outdoor temps.

[Mighty Hd]

I ran into the same problem a few weeks back.

After countless hours of reading on the board I came to the following conclusion.

It's not about the brand, it's the quality of the install that makes the unit. All of the units are basically the same.

I personally chose an Amana (higher-end Goodman).

[skippedover]

My stock answers are attached. 'Nuff said.

[richamor]

I did fail to mention that these were bring quoted and installed by licensed contractors with good reputations.
I am curious about the strengths and weakness of the two units. And although Goodman is very open with their specs, info on the York seems to be a guarded secret. Which has led me here.
Thanks again for the replies.