Rheem versus Goodman

[kirian]

Hi folks,

I saw a very old post related to a similar topic, but since it was over 3yrs old, I thought I should post a new thread (since I know quality of units can change over time).

I am buying a home that needs a new HVAC unit (specifically, the outside compressor). The sellers have agreed to replace the unit with a Goodman (quoted price with installation around $$$$$ ). The installer has also quoted a Rheem unit for $$$$ more (I would have to pay this difference).

The home is located in SE North Carolina, about 5 miles from the ocean (in case salt air plays a role in your opinion).

What is the main difference between these two manufactures (quality, warranties, future repair costs, etc)? I am spending so much of my savings just to get into this home, but I will spend the extra $$$$ if it is truly worth it. I value what all you fabulous professionals have to say :)

[2old2rock]

Make sure thy are apples to apples. Lots of different options to compare.
Post model #'s of each system and we can help.

[kirian]

Thanks 2old2Rock and Meldogg - I appreciate you replying. I have a call into the HVAC company to ask for some additional info on the 2 systems (the conversations today took place between my agent and seller's agent, so I haven't gotten all the nitty gritty details yet).

Besides making sure I am comparing apples to apples, what type of questions should I be sure to ask tomorrow when I talk with the installer? I will also get the model numbers tomorrow and post that info.

Really appreciate your help - HVAC stuff is definitely not my forte (give me toilet guts any day....lol!)

[2old2rock]

Most important question - did they perform a load calculation.

[kirian]

Thanks again, 2old2rock - I would never had know to ask that question. I really appreciate your input!

[smokin68]

Goodman offers the most bang for the buck so to speak, Rheem has smaller airhandlers if size is an issue. Goodman has flimsier metal cabinets if noise is an issue, but if installed where it should be, should be no issue. Make sure if the filter is to be changed at the airhandler(indoor unit), buy the filter cabinet when its installed( MUCH better). Good luck.

[Twilly]

Twilly says Rheem

[kangaroogod]

You were probably quoted for a base 13 seer unit I assume as it is a real estate transaction. I would pay a little extra for a 14seer goodman which will turn the standard 10yr compressor warranty to a limited lifetime one. If you are going to be in the house for the long haul that is something you may want to consider. As noted before, the installing contractor is more important than the units themselves.

[qwerty hvac]

RHEEM!!!!!!!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

[beenthere]

Meldogg21, this is the Ask Our Pro's forum, and only Pro members that have been vetted by the AOPC may post advise here. Please apply to the AOPC today, thank you.

You can find the rules for posting and qualifications here (http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/showthread.php?t=957002).


Further infractions may result in loss of posting privileges.

[kirian]

Hi again,

I have some updated info after speaking with the HVAC company.

Model #s
Goodman - GSH130301
Rheem - 13PGA30A01

Both units carry the same warranty (5yr on parts and compressor). Both are 13 seer (current unit is 10 seer). In order to go any higher, I would need to also replace the interior unit (air handler) which the HVAC person said was in excellent condition and didn't appear close to need repaired. Frankly, I cannot afford to spend the additional money to replace the interior unit just for the sake of getting a higher seer rating. The home is slightly less than 1400sqft and was built in 1997.... in case that makes a difference on your thoughts.

He said that Goodman's have improved immensely over the past several years. When asked about the difference in the units, he said the main difference was just that the Rheem was a "heavier" unit (meaning more substantially built). He agreed, before I even prompted him, that the installer makes all the difference (like you all said). He did not to try to push me toward either unit and was happy to give me the model numbers so that I could ask all of you your thoughts.

I appreciate any additional opinions you all have. Again, if I had $700 just laying around, I would go with the better unit, but at this point in the game (and with other things needing to be done once I get in the house), $700 is quite a chunk of change for me.

Thanks!

[llskywalker]

I personally like and install Goodman. I also install Rheem if that helps you. If you register the Goodman unit over the internet within 60 days of install you get an extra 5 years parts warranty just for registering, no extra cost to the client.

[jpsmith1cm]

wosh



This is the Ask Our Pro's forum. In order to post a response here, you must have verified qualifications and have been approved by the AOP Committee. You may ask a question by starting a new thread.

You can find the rules for posting and qualifications here (http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/showthread.php?t=957002).

Additional infractions may result in loss of posting privileges.

Your post has been deleted

[kangaroogod]

What is the circumstances for replacement? Was it a leak issue? A compressor failure? What type of indoor is it? Is their acid in the system? Will they be properly removing/neutralizing the acid if so? These questions are far more important than which brand at this point.