Charcoal or Gas

[ar_hvac_man]

I love to smoke and grill, both ways. What do you use?

[ACFIXR]

Howdy.AR......

Depends on the time and circumstances............

If we want something quick we use the gas grill.

If we want something really full of grilled mesquite deliciousness I fire up the mesquite grill.

http://i1201.photobucket.com/albums/bb359/Chuck_Phelan/Food/MesquiteGrillin.jpg

If I have all day and some time the day before I'll fire up the the smoker

http://i1201.photobucket.com/albums/bb359/Chuck_Phelan/Food/025-2.jpg

and stoke it with some mesquite and the family comes over and we feast on some smokey deliciousness..............

http://i1201.photobucket.com/albums/bb359/Chuck_Phelan/Food/shoulders_babybacks.jpg

Good god I want to smoke something this weekend............:cheers:

[steveoo]

gas is fast for everyday use,Charcoal has it's advantage's,try smokeing some pork with orange wood.

[dec]

Looks like I'm like everyone else ...... depends on situation at the time. Willing to do it either way being both are available :grin2:

[Tech it out]

ACFXR,,, I'm gunna HAVE to smoke something this weekend after looking at that! Dang man, there should be a law against such pics being posted on here! :cheers:

[ACFIXR]

ACFXR,,, I'm gunna HAVE to smoke something this weekend after looking at that! Dang man, there should be a law against such pics being posted on here! :cheers:

Yeah Tech, i'm chompin at the bit for Easter weekend so I have an excuse to fire it up!:cheers:

[Tech it out]

Do ya need an excuse, REALLY?

[tunnel_rat]

The gas is nice, but just can't compete with some good smoke......

[schr8er]

http://3putt.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/hank-hill.jpg

[hurtinhvac]

I was recently made a believer in charcoal and wood chips after years of gas only. Really doesn't take that long at all for only two people.

I am actually going to toss my gas grill to make room for a smoker.

ACFIXR - what's a good smoker site to do some research?

[swamp]

I was recently made a believer in charcoal and wood chips after years of gas only. Really doesn't take that long at all for only two people.
.



:ditto:

[ar_hvac_man]

I like gas for grilling hands down, that is if you have a nice grill.

Smoker with charcoal and my preference, hickory, for smoking.

[valdelocc]

I cook with wood, round here a face cord of apple cost $50 and it last a long time.

[ACFIXR]

I was recently made a believer in charcoal and wood chips after years of gas only. Really doesn't take that long at all for only two people.

I am actually going to toss my gas grill to make room for a smoker.

ACFIXR - what's a good smoker site to do some research?

I used google to see what methods the pros used. It boiled down to 2 principles= Reverse circulation and heat retention. A lot of people will tell you about controlling the air with inlet and outlet dampers and using gas to supplement the coals.But it is all a workaround for a piss poor design.

Use the reverse circulation design with thick metal and you will have a super smoker.

Google "reverse flow smoker", and remember the thicker the metal the more heat it will retain. Stay away from 50 gallon barrel type designs.

:.02:

[hurtinhvac]

I used google to see what methods the pros used. It boiled down to 2 principles= Reverse circulation and heat retention. A lot of people will tell you about controlling the air with inlet and outlet dampers and using gas to supplement the coals.But it is all a workaround for a piss poor design.

Use the reverse circulation design with thick metal and you will have a super smoker.

Google "reverse flow smoker", and remember the thicker the metal the more heat it will retain. Stay away from 50 gallon barrel type designs.

:.02:

Will do - thank you.

[venicemayer]

Charcoal is still the best when grilling meat or fish than using a gas or electric griller.

[hydra]

If I'm in a hurry I use gas but if I have all day then the smoker can't be beat! Hickory and mesquite all the way!

[Southern Mech]

The smoke ring is a great forum for all things a cookin

[viceman]

i have a bradley smoker for low and slow stuff.
my weber charcol kettle finally gave out after 10 years. i replaced it with a weber gas grill.
its my first gas grill in 25 years. i got tired of paying 8 bucks for charcol every time i wanted to cook a couple burgers. gas is easy,fast, and cheap.

[ar_hvac_man]

i have a bradley smoker for low and slow stuff.
my weber charcol kettle finally gave out after 10 years. i replaced it with a weber gas grill.
its my first gas grill in 25 years. i got tired of paying 8 bucks for charcol every time i wanted to cook a couple burgers. gas is easy,fast, and cheap.

What model? We just invested in a Weber. Pricey but built like a tank and no hot spots. Every sq inch of cooking area is as hot as the next. Its so different weve had to re-learn how to cook on it. Very nice

[chuckcrj]

I use a Traeger wood pellet grill. The best money I ever spent. You can smoke, or slow cook at what ever temp you set it for and walk away. No baby-sitting. Just turn it on and come back in 10 minutes and its hot and ready to go.

They are limited to around 450° from the factory, so I made a few modifications and now can sear steak at 600 - 700° if I want. And still have enough control to smoke at 180°

I am too lazy to use wood or charcoal, takes too long. But I really like the wood smoke flavor.

[georgehvac]

I love my weber gas grill but only use it if time is an issue and I need to get food on the grill fast. I use my charcoal grills when im grilling for flavor. The weber kettle is a great grill and can be used for smoking as well. Check out the -Big Green Egg- if your not on a tight budget. If your just starting out with smoking bbq google -uds smoker- also known as the ugly drum smoker. Its an easy to make, homemade smoker that has proven itself in competition bbq contest. Heres a bbq forum thats worth a look at -bbq-brethren dot com- go to q talk.

[ar_hvac_man]

The green egg is one of the best made. 2 or 3 inches of lump charcoal, your choice of what wood flavor you want, and you can smoke all day. You can also raise the temp to sear and cook steaks and burgers quickly. The temperature control is completely amazing once you figure out the fresh air and exhaust dampers. My buddy swears by it and after many many meals and parties over there, I am completely convinced. From a burger, rack of ribs, turkey, fall apart brisket, whatever, the egg can do it.

[drivewizard]

I use a Traeger wood pellet grill. The best money I ever spent. You can smoke, or slow cook at what ever temp you set it for and walk away. No baby-sitting. Just turn it on and come back in 10 minutes and its hot and ready to go.

They are limited to around 450° from the factory, so I made a few modifications and now can sear steak at 600 - 700° if I want. And still have enough control to smoke at 180°

I am too lazy to use wood or charcoal, takes too long. But I really like the wood smoke flavor.

I would be interested in hearing what kind of mod's you did. I have 2 Traegers, and have never been able to get over 400 deg.
If you are getting 600-700 deg, do you go through a lot of fire pots? Thanks

[chuckcrj]

I have a model 070.

I cut the restrictor rod out of the auger, so it feeds more pellets. Also wired in a switch so I can keep the auger running all the time when I grill, since the digital control will not let it go above 450°.

I got grates from grillgrate.com, which btw was the best investment I've ever made. Those grill grates really are everything they say. I would never use any other grill grate no matter what I was grilling with.

I remove the grease drip pan when I want to grill, to get more direct heat on the grates. The baffle above the fire pot got about 20 1/2 inch holes drilled in it to let more direct flame up on the grill grates.

I got my ideas from pelletheads.com. Those guys are top notch when it comes to ideas for pellet grills. They do full testing and reviews with lots of pics if you are looking to buy s new grill.

[chuckcrj]

It works fine in hot weather, but may have trouble when it gets cold. The next step would be a faster auger gear motor.

[2sac]

Charcoal or gas? How about both?
http://i289.photobucket.com/albums/ll203/slonezp/001-2.jpg
I rarely use the gas. Mostly during the wintertime because I can get a more consistent heat while grilling. I also have a Brinkman gas smoker. It's not insulated so smoking during the winter is a PITA. Year round, I found the best results is to smoke for an hour and finish off in the oven. I like a mix of hickory and apple chips for pork. I've attempted to try and smoke fish a # of times and never once been successful.

[ar_hvac_man]

Charcoal or gas? How about both?
http://i289.photobucket.com/albums/ll203/slonezp/001-2.jpg
I rarely use the gas. Mostly during the wintertime because I can get a more consistent heat while grilling. I also have a Brinkman gas smoker. It's not insulated so smoking during the winter is a PITA. Year round, I found the best results is to smoke for an hour and finish off in the oven. I like a mix of hickory and apple chips for pork. I've attempted to try and smoke fish a # of times and never once been successful.

I always finish in the oven. I like to get a couple hours of heavy smoke into the meat to get a nice smoke ring then wrap in foil leaving the ends open, pour fruit juice in(almost any will work but i prefer apple or orange), then close the ends and throw it into a 180 deg oven for as long as I can wait. Let it rest for an hour and its like butter

[hydra]

308111 snow crab and shrimp on the smoker! First time trying it and it turned out great with apple and cherry wood.

[ar_hvac_man]

Mmmmmm. Nice lookin meal right there!